Moana Railway Station

Midland Line, MOANA

Historic Place Category 1

List No. 5004

Quick links:
Considered to be an exceptionally fine remaining example of the Troup class A station, the single storeyed timber Moana Railway Station, situated beside the northern shore of Lake Brunner, was constructed in 1926 to replace the previous railway station (of similar design) that had burnt down on this exact site the year before. Designed by renowned architect and engineer, George Alexander Troup, Type A Stations were a significant group of standard design stations in New Zealand, once common but now relatively rare. The building has aesthetic, architectural, historical and social significance or value.

Kōtukuwhakaoka is the Māori name for both the Arnold River and Lake Brunner on Te Tai Poutini (the West Coast), both features being named after a visiting North Island rangatira killed by one of the two taniwha that patrolled the lake. The area has a long Māori association as a place for occupation and resources. In 1886 the Midland Railway Company was granted a 10-year concession to construct a railway from Foxhill, south of Nelson, to Springfield in Canterbury, via the Brunnerton on the West Coast. When the company opened the railway from Brunnerton in November 1892, Moana was only a flag station. The railway reached Jackson by March 1894 but then the company folded, its assets were seized by the Government in 1895 and eventually came into the ownership of New Zealand Railways (NZR). Following the opening of the railway, Pākeha settlers began establishing timber mills in the area and the Lake Brunner Sawmill Company had a 7-chain siding at Moana station in June 1895. The same month saw the opening of a new lean-to addition to the station that incorporated room for a booking office and telephone station. Other facilities at Moana in 1895 included a 200-foot-long platform and 12-chain loop (siding). Moana village, overlooking Lake Brunner, started to become a popular tourist resort by the late nineteenth century. It became a destination for ‘picnic trains’ where carriage-loads of day-trippers would disembark at this small station. Already by the early 1900s there were at least a couple of other additions to the station building (post office, telephone bureau, ladies’ waiting room). The demand for refreshments at the station resulted in the eventual erection of a tearoom addition at the western (footbridge) end of the station building in 1911. Moana was the only staffed station on the Stillwater-Otira railway line. By 1925 the facilities at Moana included fixed signals, a passenger platform, a station building, a goods shed, a loading bank, and cattle and sheep yards. In the yard there was a crossing loop able to hold 69 wagons, a loop (30 wagons), goods shed siding loop (14 wagons), and two backshunts both able to hold 12 wagons. On 15 April 1926, the railway station and refreshment rooms were burnt to the ground by a fire which started in the women's waiting room. A temporary railways hut was used at Moana until a new station could be erected but the Railways Department decided not to rebuild the tearooms at this time.

Set within the wider context of the Moana Railway Station Historic Area, the present Moana Railway Station building is slightly larger than that which burnt down. It was built under the supervision of John Mahoney, foreman of works for the West Coast, and completed by October 1926 at a cost of approximately £800. The building has a gable pitch roof above a lean-to timber structure with adjoining verandah. The exterior has rusticated weatherboard cladding and the roof is corrugated steel. The building is a Troup Class A design, incorporating (when built) an office, lobby, ladies’ waiting room and toilet, but in the reverse order to the standard design. The main entrance, situated towards the east end of the north elevation facing the rail tracks, is a pair of double doors and fanlights, flanked by narrow sash windows. A line of wider sash windows is to its west, and at the west end of the north elevation is the former postal lobby, accessed by its own door. Interior rooms have horizontal tongue-and-groove lining. The main office contains a fireplace and, like the lobby, has windows on the south side with views to Lake Brunner.

In 1967 the Railways Department decided to make Moana an attended flag station, something that had been attempted earlier in 1942 and again threatened in 1953. In late 1985 the station was closed to all traffic except passengers and parcels. At some point, the verandah of the Moana Railway Station building was cut back to fit modern railway wagon profiles. The Moana Railway Station is still in use and Moana remains a popular stop for passengers on the TranzAlpine train.
Moana Railway Station. Image courtesy of www.flickr.com | Shellie Evans – flyingkiwigirl | 22/04/2015 | Shellie Evans – flyingkiwigirl
Moana Railway Station. Image courtesy of www.flickr.com | Walgert (Flickr) | 21/07/2008 | Walgert (Flickr)
Moana Railway Station. Image courtesy of www.flickr.com | Shellie Evans – flyingkiwigirl | 22/04/2015 | Shellie Evans – flyingkiwigirl

List Entry Information

Overview

Status

Listed

List Entry Status

Historic Place Category 1

Access

Private/No Public Access

List Number

5004

Date Entered

28th June 1990

Date of Effect

28th June 1990

City/District Council

Grey District

Region

West Coast Region

Extent of List Entry

Extent includes part of the land described as Railway Land as shown on SO 876 & SO 9468, Westland Land District and the Moana Railway Station building thereon. Refer to the extent map tabled at the Heritage List/ Rārangi Kōrero Committee meeting on 30 July 2020.

Legal description

Railway Land as shown on SO 876 & SO 9468, Westland Land District

Location Description

The Moana Railway Station is located on the Midland Line which is adjacent to Ana Street, MOANA

Status

Listed

List Entry Status

Historic Place Category 1

Access

Private/No Public Access

List Number

5004

Date Entered

28th June 1990

Date of Effect

28th June 1990

City/District Council

Grey District

Region

West Coast Region

Extent of List Entry

Extent includes part of the land described as Railway Land as shown on SO 876 & SO 9468, Westland Land District and the Moana Railway Station building thereon. Refer to the extent map tabled at the Heritage List/ Rārangi Kōrero Committee meeting on 30 July 2020.

Legal description

Railway Land as shown on SO 876 & SO 9468, Westland Land District

Location Description

The Moana Railway Station is located on the Midland Line which is adjacent to Ana Street, MOANA

Significance

Why is this place significant?

Historic Significance

Historical Significance or Value The Moana Station was the main crossing station for trains on the Midland line and the only staffed one on the Stillwater to Otira line and as such its staff were responsible for the operation of the nearby milling stations at Kotuku, Ruru and Te Kinga. Moana was also important for the 'picnic' trains bringing people to Lake Brunner.

Physical Significance

ARCHITECTURAL QUALITY: The Type A stations were the smallest of the standard designs for staffed stations updated by George Troup in 1904 in his capacity as Office and Designing Engineer of the Railways Department. Type A once accounted for about fifteen per cent of all railway stations in New Zealand. Standardisation of design allowed the Railways Department to economise on the construction of railway stations. Troup's revised designs were slightly more decorative and used more substantial door and window joinery than those erected before 1900. Standard design railway stations and their direct variations once accounted for over eighty per cent of all station buildings in the country, but Moana Railway Station is the only type A which is still extant in New Zealand with its associated sidings and goods sheds. It is important as representing Type A Stations, a significant group of standard design stations in New Zealand. TOWNSCAPE/LANDMARK VALUE: The railway station at Moana is a modest structure which stands in a picturesque environment and makes an important contribution to the townscape of Moana, particularly because its immediate railway environment has been preserved.

Why is this place significant?

Historic Significance

Historical Significance or Value The Moana Station was the main crossing station for trains on the Midland line and the only staffed one on the Stillwater to Otira line and as such its staff were responsible for the operation of the nearby milling stations at Kotuku, Ruru and Te Kinga. Moana was also important for the 'picnic' trains bringing people to Lake Brunner.

Physical Significance

ARCHITECTURAL QUALITY: The Type A stations were the smallest of the standard designs for staffed stations updated by George Troup in 1904 in his capacity as Office and Designing Engineer of the Railways Department. Type A once accounted for about fifteen per cent of all railway stations in New Zealand. Standardisation of design allowed the Railways Department to economise on the construction of railway stations. Troup's revised designs were slightly more decorative and used more substantial door and window joinery than those erected before 1900. Standard design railway stations and their direct variations once accounted for over eighty per cent of all station buildings in the country, but Moana Railway Station is the only type A which is still extant in New Zealand with its associated sidings and goods sheds. It is important as representing Type A Stations, a significant group of standard design stations in New Zealand. TOWNSCAPE/LANDMARK VALUE: The railway station at Moana is a modest structure which stands in a picturesque environment and makes an important contribution to the townscape of Moana, particularly because its immediate railway environment has been preserved.

Construction Information

Construction Professional

Name

Troup, George Alexander

Type

Architect

Biography

G A Troup (1863-1941) was born in London in 1863 and educated in Scotland. He trained as an architect and engineer under C E Calvert of Edinburgh and came to New Zealand in 1884. After a short time with the Survey Department in Otago he became a draughtsman for New Zealand Railways in Dunedin and then, from 1888, in Wellington. Troup became Chief Draughtsman in 1894. He designed many station buildings throughout the county, some of which are still in use today; these buildings form an important part of New Zealand's landscape. His best known building is the Dunedin Railway Station (1904-07). He also designed the head office building in Wellington for Railways (1901, now demolished). Troup became a Fellow of the Royal Institute of British Architects in 1907. After World War I he was promoted to head the newly established Architectural Branch of New Zealand Railways. On retirement from Railways in 1925 he entered local body politics and was Mayor of Wellington from 1927 to 1931. Troup was prominent in the Presbyterian Church and founded the Presbyterian Young Men's Bible Class Union. He was an elder of the church for 47 years and also served on the governing bodies of several Wellington secondary schools. Education was a life-long interest and he was keenly involved in the training of engineering cadets in New Zealand Railways. Troup was knighted in 1937 and died in 1941. Last updated 1 October 2014 See also: James Veitch. 'Troup, George Alexander', Dictionary of New Zealand Biography, first published in 1993. Te Ara - the Encyclopedia of New Zealand, https://teara.govt.nz/en/biographies/2t49/troup-george-alexander

Construction Details

Start Year

1895

Type

Original Construction

Description

Lean-to station building (with booking office and telephone station) and platform built

Start Year

1901

Type

Modification

Description

Station extended and fireplace put in.

Start Year

1911

Type

Refurbishment/renovation

Description

Station building extended at west end (refreshment rooms)

Start Year

1926

Type

Demolished - Fire

Description

Railway Station building destroyed by fire

Start Year

1926

Type

Original Construction

Description

replacement Railway Station building constructed

Start Year

1892

Type

Original Construction

Description

Opening of railway line from Brunner to Moana, Lake Brunner

Start Year

1958

Type

Modification

Description

Platform front renewed in concrete and platform shortened to 78 metres.

Type

Modification

Description

Front section of verandah removed to accommodate modern railway loads.

Construction Materials

Rusticated weatherboards. Corrugated iron roof. Railway irons support the verandah roof.

Construction Professional

Name

Troup, George Alexander

Type

Architect

Biography

G A Troup (1863-1941) was born in London in 1863 and educated in Scotland. He trained as an architect and engineer under C E Calvert of Edinburgh and came to New Zealand in 1884. After a short time with the Survey Department in Otago he became a draughtsman for New Zealand Railways in Dunedin and then, from 1888, in Wellington. Troup became Chief Draughtsman in 1894. He designed many station buildings throughout the county, some of which are still in use today; these buildings form an important part of New Zealand's landscape. His best known building is the Dunedin Railway Station (1904-07). He also designed the head office building in Wellington for Railways (1901, now demolished). Troup became a Fellow of the Royal Institute of British Architects in 1907. After World War I he was promoted to head the newly established Architectural Branch of New Zealand Railways. On retirement from Railways in 1925 he entered local body politics and was Mayor of Wellington from 1927 to 1931. Troup was prominent in the Presbyterian Church and founded the Presbyterian Young Men's Bible Class Union. He was an elder of the church for 47 years and also served on the governing bodies of several Wellington secondary schools. Education was a life-long interest and he was keenly involved in the training of engineering cadets in New Zealand Railways. Troup was knighted in 1937 and died in 1941. Last updated 1 October 2014 See also: James Veitch. 'Troup, George Alexander', Dictionary of New Zealand Biography, first published in 1993. Te Ara - the Encyclopedia of New Zealand, https://teara.govt.nz/en/biographies/2t49/troup-george-alexander

Construction Details

Start Year

1895

Type

Original Construction

Description

Lean-to station building (with booking office and telephone station) and platform built

Start Year

1901

Type

Modification

Description

Station extended and fireplace put in.

Start Year

1911

Type

Refurbishment/renovation

Description

Station building extended at west end (refreshment rooms)

Start Year

1926

Type

Demolished - Fire

Description

Railway Station building destroyed by fire

Start Year

1926

Type

Original Construction

Description

replacement Railway Station building constructed

Start Year

1892

Type

Original Construction

Description

Opening of railway line from Brunner to Moana, Lake Brunner

Start Year

1958

Type

Modification

Description

Platform front renewed in concrete and platform shortened to 78 metres.

Type

Modification

Description

Front section of verandah removed to accommodate modern railway loads.

Construction Materials

Rusticated weatherboards. Corrugated iron roof. Railway irons support the verandah roof.

Physical Description

ARCHITECTURAL DESCRIPTION: The station is built to the standard type A design, consisting of office, lobby, women's waiting room and women's toilet. As built, the main entry was from the platform through a pair of double doors. These doors have a fanlight and are flanked by narrow sash windows. This association of double doors and windows was a typical Troup station architectural feature. Internal doors link the other rooms. All rooms have horizontal tongue and groove lining. At the west end is a postal lobby with separate entrance from the platform. The office has a fireplace built of tapestry bricks with an external chimney breast. There is a ticket window into the lobby, and a service hatch into the postal lobby. Moana Station is built as the mirror image of a standard A design. This was presumably to ensure that visitors using the overbridge would arrive at the post office first and the toilets last! The office and lobby have windows in the back wall to provide fine lake views. At some time the women's waiting room has been connected to a lobby open to the platform. The verandah which shelters the station platform is supported by six railway irons which are bolted to the front of the station building and bend out to meet the verandah eaves. The ends of the verandah are fitted with vertical valances which have been cut so as to form a scalloped edge which is the only decorative feature of the building. Approximately one hundred metres west of the station is a pedestrian overbridge which is the only all wooden example of its kind left in New Zealand. MODIFICATIONS: 1958 - Platform front renewed in concrete and platform shortened to 78 metres. Date Unknown - Front section of verandah removed to accommodate modern railway loads.

ARCHITECTURAL DESCRIPTION: The station is built to the standard type A design, consisting of office, lobby, women's waiting room and women's toilet. As built, the main entry was from the platform through a pair of double doors. These doors have a fanlight and are flanked by narrow sash windows. This association of double doors and windows was a typical Troup station architectural feature. Internal doors link the other rooms. All rooms have horizontal tongue and groove lining. At the west end is a postal lobby with separate entrance from the platform. The office has a fireplace built of tapestry bricks with an external chimney breast. There is a ticket window into the lobby, and a service hatch into the postal lobby. Moana Station is built as the mirror image of a standard A design. This was presumably to ensure that visitors using the overbridge would arrive at the post office first and the toilets last! The office and lobby have windows in the back wall to provide fine lake views. At some time the women's waiting room has been connected to a lobby open to the platform. The verandah which shelters the station platform is supported by six railway irons which are bolted to the front of the station building and bend out to meet the verandah eaves. The ends of the verandah are fitted with vertical valances which have been cut so as to form a scalloped edge which is the only decorative feature of the building. Approximately one hundred metres west of the station is a pedestrian overbridge which is the only all wooden example of its kind left in New Zealand. MODIFICATIONS: 1958 - Platform front renewed in concrete and platform shortened to 78 metres. Date Unknown - Front section of verandah removed to accommodate modern railway loads.

Reference

Historical and Associated Iwi / Hapū / Whānau

Completion Date

31st January 2022

Report Written By

Robyn Burgess

Information Sources

Archives New Zealand (Chch)

Archives New Zealand (Christchurch)

Mahoney, 1987

J. D. Mahoney, Down at the Station: A Study of the New Zealand Railway Station, Palmerston North, 1987

Troup, 1982

G. Troup, George Troup: Architect and Engineer, Palmerston North, 1982

University of Canterbury

University of Canterbury

West Coast Scrapbook

West Coast Scrapbook

Wright, 2010

Wright, Stephen and Andrew Wright, West of the Divide: More Memories of the Midland Line, 2010

Other Information

A fully referenced copy of an upgrade report can be requested from the Southern Regional Office of Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga. This historic place was registered under the Historic Places Act 1980. This report includes the text from the original Building Classification Committee report considered by the NZHPT Board at the time of registration. Please note that entry on the New Zealand Heritage List/Rarangi Korero identifies only the heritage values of the property concerned, and should not be construed as advice on the state of the property, or as a comment of its soundness or safety, including in regard to earthquake risk, safety in the event of fire, or insanitary conditions.

Historical and Associated Iwi / Hapū / Whānau

Completion Date

31st January 2022

Report Written By

Robyn Burgess

Information Sources

Archives New Zealand (Chch)

Archives New Zealand (Christchurch)

Mahoney, 1987

J. D. Mahoney, Down at the Station: A Study of the New Zealand Railway Station, Palmerston North, 1987

Troup, 1982

G. Troup, George Troup: Architect and Engineer, Palmerston North, 1982

University of Canterbury

University of Canterbury

West Coast Scrapbook

West Coast Scrapbook

Wright, 2010

Wright, Stephen and Andrew Wright, West of the Divide: More Memories of the Midland Line, 2010

Other Information

A fully referenced copy of an upgrade report can be requested from the Southern Regional Office of Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga. This historic place was registered under the Historic Places Act 1980. This report includes the text from the original Building Classification Committee report considered by the NZHPT Board at the time of registration. Please note that entry on the New Zealand Heritage List/Rarangi Korero identifies only the heritage values of the property concerned, and should not be construed as advice on the state of the property, or as a comment of its soundness or safety, including in regard to earthquake risk, safety in the event of fire, or insanitary conditions.

Further Information

Former Usages

General Usage: Transport

Specific Usage: Railway station/ platform/ refreshment room

Former Usages

General Usage: Transport

Specific Usage: Railway station/ platform/ refreshment room

Stay up to date with Heritage this month